Matthew’s

Baltimore’s
First Pizzeria

Matthew’s Pizza has been featured on The Food Network, Baltimore Magazine, and Baltimore Sun. It was named the best pizza in Maryland by Yahoo Food.

Order Now  (410) 276‑8755

“Marvel at the
Perfect Pizza

-Baltimore Magazine

Menu Favorites

Crab Pie

Boneless Wings

Meatball Sub

Both Cheese Pie

Garlic Bread

Cold Cut Sub

Meat Lovers

Crispini

Sausage Sub

Since 1943

Matthew’s is the city’s oldest pizzeria, established in 1943 in East Baltimore’s neighborhood of Highlandtown in Baltimore, featuring a unique dough that is a well-kept secret.

Beginning as a small father and son bakery providing the locals with Tomato Pies. Matthew’s is still locally owned and operated.

We are proud of our long-standing reputation and continue to pride ourselves on quality.

Matthew’s Pizza has been featured on The Food Network, Baltimore Magazine, and Baltimore Sun. It was named the best pizza in Maryland by Yahoo Food.

“Matthew's Pizzeria is an unexpected gem. Fabulous deep-dish pizza, reasonable prices, and great service.”

"It calls itself Baltimore’s first pizzeria, and it very well could be its best as well. Its individual-size pies have the sweetest, freshest tomato sauce in town."

"The chowhounds say there are many wonderful restaurants in Baltimore Matthew’s Pizza, on Eastern Avenue, is a winner."

Dine with Us

(410) 276‑8755
3131 Eastern Avenue
Baltimore, MD 21224

Opening Hours

Mon-Sat: 11am – 9pm
Sun: 12pm – 8pm