Baltimore's Best Pizza.
Best Pizza Balt. Mag. '83
Best Pizza Balt. Mag. '88
Best Pizza Balt. Mag. '93
Best Pizza washingtonpost.com '96
Best Pizza Balt. Mag. '97
Best Pizza City Paper '97
Best Pizza City Paper '98
Best Pizza MSN.com audience & editorial winner '01, '02
Best Pizza (“Eastern US”) pizzatherapy.com '02
Best Pizza DigitalCity.com, Editor’s pick '02
Best Pizza The Sun '02
Best Pizza City Paper '03 [editor]
Best Pizza City
Paper '03 [reader’s poll]
Best Pizza MSN.com audience & editorial winner '03
“Best of the Best” {The People’s Choice} Pizza: Matthews Pizzeria Balt. Mag. '03
Best Pizza : Matthew’s Pizza {Readers’ Poll} Balt. Mag.
50 SPOTS FOR GREAT FOOD TO GO, Baltimore magazine '99
Cheap Eats! Great Dining Value., Baltimore Magazine 2003
“...the best pizza in Baltimore is..Matthew’s Pizza on Eastern Avenue..” , Washingtonpost.com '96
Best Classic Pizza Joint , Baltimore Magazine 83 & 88
“THE BEST OF THE BEST” We let you tell us who’s the best of the best. We asked, and you answered: Which restaurants...do you consider the best? The response was overwhelming, the most we’ve ever received. Pizza: Matthew’s Pizzeria , [THE PEOPLE’S CHOICE] Balt. Mag. 03
Baltimore’s…best pizzeria. , Jacques Kelly The Sun
“Matthew’s [Pizza]...a slice of heaven” The Sun 04 [Food: 4 Stars(Outstanding); Service: 3 1/2 Stars] , National Public Radio, Food Panel: “Matthew’s Pizza is the best.” 11/04
“I had my first date at the Patterson Theater and my first pizza at MATTHEW’S PIZZA.”, U. S. Senator Barbara Mikulski Highlandtown Festival Oct 98
"I travel 20 miles for a Matthew’s Pizza.", Marty Bass, WJZ 13 Eyewitness News